GUIDE · 14 NOVEMBER 2026

Image quality settings when converting: should you choose High, Balanced or Small?

Learn which image quality settings when converting suit your files: High for editing and print, Balanced for everyday use, Small for email and uploads.

Last updated: 14 November 2026

For most photos, choose Balanced. Use High for files you will edit again, print or archive, and Small for email, uploads and anything viewed on a screen at modest size. These image quality settings when converting only matter for lossy formats such as JPEG and WebP, where a lower setting discards some detail in exchange for a smaller file.

Our guide to converting files on a Mac covers the wider set of options. This article focuses on one decision: which quality level to pick when you convert images.

What does the quality setting actually change?

The quality setting controls how much visual information a lossy format throws away. Higher quality keeps more fine detail and gives a bigger file. Lower quality compresses harder and gives a smaller file with more visible artifacts.

JPEG and WebP (in its lossy mode) work by approximating the image. The encoder simplifies areas the eye is less sensitive to, such as subtle colour shifts and very fine texture. A low setting simplifies a lot, and you start to see:

  • Blocky patches in smooth areas such as sky or skin.
  • Fuzzy "mosquito" noise around sharp edges and text.
  • Banding in gradients.
  • Muddy fine detail such as foliage, hair and fabric.

Two things are worth knowing:

  • The relationship isn't linear. Going from the top setting to a slightly lower one usually saves a lot of space with little visible change. Going from a middle setting to a very low one saves less space and costs a lot more quality. That is why a mid-level option is usually the sensible default.
  • Results depend on the picture. A flat screenshot or a photo with soft backgrounds compresses well. A busy photo full of texture produces a much larger file at the same setting. Any exact file-size figure for a given setting is therefore only an example, not a promise.

Formats such as PNG are lossless. They keep every pixel, so a quality slider doesn't apply to them in the same way, and that is why converters offer quality choices only "when the format supports it".

Which setting should you choose: High, Balanced or Small?

Pick the setting by what happens to the file next. If it will be edited again or printed, choose High. If it is for general sharing and storage, choose Balanced. If size limits matter more than perfect detail, choose Small.

Convert2Any offers three levels: High (keep more detail), Balanced (the recommended default) and Small (save more space). Here is how to match them to a job.

Your situationSuggested levelWhy
Photos you will edit, crop heavily or retouchHighEach re-save of a lossy file loses a little more. Start from the best copy you can.
Prints, photo books, portfolio workHighPrinting and large displays reveal artifacts that a phone screen hides.
Archiving originals you can't re-shootHighKeep the most information while you still have it.
Everyday sharing, albums, sending to familyBalancedLooks the same at normal viewing size, with a noticeably smaller file.
Converting HEIC from an iPhone so others can open itBalancedMaximum compatibility without bloating the folder.
Website images, blog posts, product listingsBalanced, or Small for thumbnailsPage weight affects loading speed, and most images display smaller than their full size.
Email attachments, forms with size limits, chat appsSmallMeeting a size limit matters more than the last bit of detail.
Screenshots with textHigh, or keep PNGText edges show compression artifacts first.

When Balanced is enough

Most images are viewed on a phone, laptop or tablet at a size smaller than the original pixels. At that size, the differences between a high setting and a balanced one are hard to spot. A balanced conversion is the right call for the bulk of a camera roll, vacation photos and ordinary documents-as-images.

When to pay for High

Choose High when the file is a source for later work. Editing amplifies compression artifacts: brightening shadows, sharpening or increasing contrast can reveal blockiness that was invisible before. Printing also tends to expose problems that were hidden on screen. If you aren't sure, High costs you only disk space, which is easy to reclaim later.

When Small is the right choice

Small is for output you won't revisit: a photo attached to an email, an image going into a form with a size cap, or a quick preview. Keep your originals and treat the Small version as disposable. Don't go back and convert a Small file to something else expecting quality to return. The detail is already gone.

Does converting HEIC to JPG lose quality?

Yes, a little, because both HEIC and JPEG are lossy and the conversion re-encodes the picture. In practice, a High or Balanced setting keeps the result visually very close for normal viewing.

The practical advice for iPhone photos:

  • Keep the original HEIC files if you can. They are your best-quality source.
  • Convert copies for sharing with people or services that can't open HEIC.
  • Use Balanced for general sharing and High if the photos will be printed or edited.

For the full walkthrough, see how to convert HEIC to JPG on a Mac in batches.

How can you test the right setting on your own files?

Convert the same three or four representative images at each level, compare them at the size you'll actually use, and keep the smallest result that you can't tell apart from the best. This takes a few minutes and beats any rule of thumb.

  • Pick test images that are hard. Include one with fine texture (foliage, fabric), one with smooth gradients (sky), and one with text or sharp edges.
  • Convert them at all three levels. Save the results into separate folders, or add a suffix to each so they don't overwrite each other.
  • Check the file sizes. Note the difference between High, Balanced and Small for your own images.
  • Compare at the real viewing size. Open them at the size your audience will see. For a website, that might be 800 pixels wide, not zoomed to 400%.
  • Zoom in only to understand the limits. Look at 100% zoom on the hard areas to see where Small starts to break down.
  • Choose the smallest one that passes. If Balanced looks identical at your viewing size, you have your default.

A good habit is to decide once per type of job, not per file. For example: "family photos are Balanced, print jobs are High, email attachments are Small." Then apply it to the whole batch.

What mistakes should you avoid with quality settings?

The most common mistakes are re-compressing already-compressed files, using Small as the default, and overwriting the original. All three are easy to avoid with a little planning.

  • Converting lossy to lossy repeatedly. Each pass discards more information. Go from the original once, and avoid chains like HEIC to JPEG to a smaller JPEG to WebP.
  • Expecting a bigger file to look better. Converting a Small JPEG to a High JPEG makes a larger file with the same damage. Quality can't be restored.
  • Choosing the smallest setting by default. Storage is cheap. Reserve Small for cases with a real size limit.
  • Overwriting your originals. Save converted files beside the original with a different format, or in a separate folder you choose, so the source remains intact.
  • Using JPEG for graphics with flat colour and text. Logos, diagrams and screenshots usually look cleaner and compress well in a lossless format such as PNG.
  • Ignoring dimensions. If a file is far larger in pixels than its display size, resizing it often saves more space than lowering quality, with less visible damage.

If you have many files to convert, set the level once and apply it to the whole batch. Our article on batch converting files on a Mac shows how to do that without repeating steps.

Convert2Any lets you pick High, Balanced or Small when you choose the output format, and process the batch on your own Mac, saving next to the originals or in a folder you select.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best quality setting for converting photos?

Balanced is the best starting point for most photos. It keeps enough detail for normal viewing while producing a noticeably smaller file than High. Step up to High for editing or printing, and down to Small only when a size limit forces it.

Is there a difference between quality and file size?

Yes, but they move together only roughly. Higher quality generally means a larger file, but the exact size depends on the picture. Busy, detailed images grow much more than simple ones at the same setting.

Can I restore quality after converting to Small?

No. Lossy compression discards information permanently, and converting the result to a higher setting only makes the file bigger. Keep your originals and reconvert from them if you need better quality.

Do quality settings apply to PNG?

Not in the same way. PNG is lossless, so it keeps every pixel, and converters generally offer quality choices only for formats that support them. Converting a PNG to JPEG, however, does involve a quality choice.

Does my file leave my computer when I convert it?

With Convert2Any, no. Its site says conversion happens on your computer, with no upload step, and that the app asks before downloading any additional converter support. If privacy is a deciding factor, our comparison of offline and online file converters explains the trade-offs.

Explore supported formats Back to Blog